Draft Grade: INC, With sacrificing so many picks for future picks Incomplete is the only option, but there is a lot of work to be done still
Players Acquired during the 2013 NFL Draft (pick round, pick, overall, ESPN Overall Ranking)
Round 1 (6) (6) (ESPN: 11) : Barkevious Mingo, LB, LSU
Round 2: Forfeit, Supplemental Draft: Josh Gordon, WR, Baylor/Utah
Round 3 (6) (68) (ESPN: 156): Leon McFadden, CB, SDSU
Round 4 (111): Traded for Pittsburgh 3rd Round pick in 2014
Round 5 (139): Traded to Indianolpolis for 4th Round pick in 2014
Round 6 (7) (175) (ESPN: 230) Jamoris Slaughter, S, Notre Dame
Round 7 (11) (217) (ESPN: 201): Armonty Bryant, DE, East Central Oklahoma (Div II)
Round 7 (21) (227) (ESPN: 196): Garret Gilkey, OG, Chardon State (Div II)
*Devone Bess, WR, MIA was acquired during this draft as a result of a trade of picks
So, if the rumor that I am starting is true, that there will in fact be a Division II in the NFL, the Browns have a leg up. Obviously that is not happening, so why the Browns selected multiple Division II players, one who is dealing with a suspended sentence of 5 years for, anyone? Anyone know what this brilliant mind got arrested for? Selling weed, that is probably not wise. But what is even less wise, selling it at football practice as Armonty Bryant was doing. People say he is a beast, huge character baggage he does actually have 5 years hanging over his head. This is a problem. Anyways, Phil Taylor gingerly tossed someone (as I picture it happening) threw a window. He seems pretty rad.
I was intrigued by this decision, it got me to thinking. When the Browns were sitting at pick 68 and certainly targeting a CB, had a few options, McFadden (who they took), the CB from Connecticut, and the Honey Badger. They didn't take the Honey Badger, he was selected with the very next pick by Arizona. I thought, Wow, Browns are thinking high character, then they go after someone with a sentence over his head! I think that there is nothing exciting about this draft, other than getting picks for next year.
Round 1 (6) (6) (ESPN: 11) : Barkevious Mingo, LB, LSU (Height: 6 foot 4, 241 Lb.)
Exciting possibilities, does not really address the needs at CB, but many believe a better pass rush makes a better CB (However, the inverse must also be true by that logic). I think he would have been available later, and a trade could have netted many valuable picks. Overall though, I give this pick a B+. That was the consensus of the other die-hard Browns fans in the Dawg Pound Sports Bar (I am trying different names for the Basement).
Round 2: Forfeit, Supplemental Draft: Josh Gordon, WR, Baylor/Utah (Height: 6 foot 3, 225 Lb.)
Many people would not count Josh in this list because it was a supplemental pick. Nonetheless it counted as a pick for this year, so I am counting in the recap, I can do whatever I want on my damn blog. Anyways, what do we get from Gordon
2012 Stat Line: 50 Receptions, 805 yards, 16.1 YPC, 5 TD
This line is impressive not for any reason except, this was in the NFL. He was the leading receiver on a the Browns last year, and this year he gets training camp. He is a great player and the character questions seem to be cleared up. He is an excellent pick in this draft!
Round 3 (6) (68) (ESPN: 156): Leon McFadden, CB, SDSU (Height: 5 foot 9.5, Weight: 193)
I think that CB was a great need here. But why not consider the Honey Badger here? Obviously a spotted past is not an issue with this regime. I don't know a lot about him, not thrilled by the pick, but at least it took care of a need. Maybe this guy is a stud, but I think that the value was the big issue. There were still good TE and other CBs available at this point.
Round 4 (111): Traded for Pittsburgh 3rd Round pick in 2014
I am glad that we got a pick for next year from Pittsburgh, however this is the first time since the 60s that we have traded with Shittsburgh. They took a study corner at Pick 111 in the 4th round, he was an Overall rating of 79 on ESPN, Shamarko Thomas, Syracuse. Why do I have a feeling that was not a good decision and that Pittsburgh is laughing at us, like usual. Probably won't be too great of a third rounder next year as Sharmarko will lead them on a deep play off run, while laughing at us.
It is always good to stockpile picks for next year. But the water is leaking pretty badly, lots of holes need to be filled. I watched the elite franchises in the draft, and I watch Cleveland. and the draft approaches are so different. Cleveland seems a little confused sometimes, and vulnerable. It just seems like the elite franchises are taking advantage of our collective stupidity.
Round 5 (139): Traded to Indianapolis for 4th Round pick in 2014
By this point, the draft was thinning out fast. A trade back into the fourth is a positive, but I feel like the draft, at some point, should involve the selection of actual players, that can help your team, today. Maybe I am naive and this draft was so bad, but many other teams seemed to be selecting some amazing players, that would have filled some huge holes for the Browns. Moving on.
Round 6 (7) (175) (ESPN: 230) Jamoris Slaughter, S, Notre Dame (Height:6 feet, Weight: 195 Lbs.)
Don't get too excited 1980s Browns fans, no relation to Webster Slaughter (Who, by the way, dunked on one of my High School Teachers at a Browns vs. Hudson High School Faculty game). This guy has a pretty great name, as did another available Safety, much higher rated as well, Baccari Rambo, S, Georgia. Safety is a need, Ward is solid, but can't do it all alone. This guy seems to have quite a list of injuries ankle, Achilles and meniscus, yikes, and you were concerned about Milliner having Hernia surgery? Are you kidding me!
Round 7 (11) (217) (ESPN: 201): Armonty Bryant, DE, East Central Oklahoma (Div II) (Height: 6 foot 4, Weight: 263)
Another DE? Are you kidding me? Probably would have been a much earlier pick, but character issued stopped that. Big and atheltic, but it is not that hard to look dominant against a DII school. Wasn't even that great at showing his athleticism at the combine either. I am still concerned about TE and FB at this point. The guy I really liked was the FB from Wake Forrest that went a few pick earlier.
Round 7 (21) (227) (ESPN: 196): Garret Gilkey, OG, Chardon State (Div II) (Height:6 foot 6, Weight: 318)
Well, at least they got a Guard! I am not sure that going for another DII player was the best decision. I feel as if TE and FB were totally neglected! This guy could be good, he is big, fairly athletic, and has good feet. I would love to say I knew more, but I only watched a view Chardon State games on ESPN 23 last year.
*Devone Bess, WR, MIA (Height: 5 foot 10, Weight: 193) was acquired during this draft as a result of a trade of picks
The Browns swapped around some picks to get this guy. I think this is a wise decision. With that being said, I was curious to see how those swaps worked out. It turned out that Cleveland ended up not getting another option to draft Ryan Nassib. While they may not have been thinking this, it did create an interesting situation that he went at 110. But I think Bess is a solid receiver.
2012 Stats: 778 yards, 61 catches, 1 TD
Career: 3447 yards, 321 catches, 12 TD
Brief Draft Review
Overall, I do not think this was the most exciting draft ever. I think that value was completely neglected, as well as addressing glaring needs with non-starter caliber players. Some of these players could turn out well,
but it was not a sexy draft. Areas of need may have been ignored entirely.
Areas of Need
Corner Back
he secondary still looks like Swiss cheese. Haden is starting CB and McFadden (second round pick) may be the other starting side? Skrine is apparently more capable at defending the slot, he seems more capable of defending a blind 12 year old school girl. I wouldn't be suprised to sign another free agent CB in the near future. McFadden was not a bad pick, but there were better options, like getting the top CB in the draft at the 6 pick, or make some trades to have picked one in the second round. Kiper is saying that McFadden has the chance to start this year, because of ability? Probably more because of necessity.
Front Seven
I think Mingo does have a shot to start, but this means Sheerd will not. To me, this is unfortunate, I think he is being given a bad break. The front seven should be decent by now, at least serviceable this year. This was a major area of need, but largely addressed in free agency, and by no means as big of a hole corner back. Armonty Bryant was a pick that could have represented value, but the character baggage is huge, and at that point there were still many huge holes that could have been filled, even with a late round pick.
Tight End
Not one pick addressed this need. The TE position was entirely ignored at the draft. The two free agent signings at TE are not the answer, more of depth moves. However, I did have a theory about the TE position David Nelson is huge receiver who frequently played on the inside at Buffalo. Is it possible that Nelson could play a hybrid TE and WR. I would love that! I am completely speculating on this, but that would be very useful and the guy looks like a TE!
Offensive Guard
A decent guard in Garret Gilky was probably not a bad pick, however, it is unlikely that he will start this year. A better guard would have been a wise selection in the earlier rounds, or when the Browns were busy handing away draft picks for next years. Some people really like Gilky, I am always a little wary of DII products, particularly on the line. I would have been happy with a Guard selected earlier, even in a trade in the first round.
Wide Receiver
This is now a point of depth for the Browns. They have a plethora of decent, and experienced WR. I think that this only a great thing. They have receivers in all shapes and sizes, which will give them so many options. I like the receiving corps at this point!
Safety
Slaughter was not the bets available Safety when they drafted him. They traded away numerous picks that would have addressed this need much earlier. I am probably more worried about Safety than I am about CB. I think that all the injuries Slaughter had made him undraftable, nope, three potentially career ending injuries don't scare the Browns!
Quarterback
Well, they had chances at drafting almost all quarterbacks, most twice, and passed. This is not the worst move. I think next years QB crop is going to be much better than this one. So passing was wise. I really thought they would have made a late move on Matt Scott, or Ryan Nassib. If you don't a QB can play, don't draft him, or you wind up with Brandon Weeden.
Overall this draft was acceptable. The grade must be incomplete because of the trades. We have done very well in free agency, but I think this draft will be more remembered from the Browns standpoint, as missed opportunities. Dee Milliner would have been a great choice at 6, and then filled out the draft from there. I know a lot of people don't believe in drafting on need, but it should be a factor. I feel as if the Browns management did exactly what I would have expected, nothing of note.
Most experts give the Browns a C+ grade. That may be a little generous. I think that the draft could have been something special, as it had depth at the CB and on the lines, all points of need. Yet, they got very little of valuable sure fire starters, at positions that lacked depth.
Look later or tomorrow for a review of undrafted free agents signed!